Did you know you can download our entire database for free?


Georgia Caselaw:
Greatest Hits

Georgia Code: Browse

(external) Findlaw Georgia Law Resources

This site exists because of donors like you.

Thanks! Georgia Caselaw
Action on insurance money. Fulton Civil Court. Before Judge Webb.
JORDAN, Judge.
John P. Thompson commenced this action in the Civil Court of Fulton County, on May 26, 1966, against the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, to recover weekly sickness and accident benefits allegedly due under a group insurance policy issued to General Motors Corporation by the insurer, under which the insurer had issued the plaintiff a certificate of coverage effective October 1, 1961. The claim is for an injury which the plaintiff allegedly incurred on May 14, 1963. Under the terms of the group policy as shown by the certificate of coverage attached to the petition, the plaintiff had two years from the time within which proof of claim was required to commence an action. He commenced the action after the expiration of this period, but within three years. The trial judge sustained a general demurrer to the petition and the plaintiff appeals from this judgment.
The controlling issue before this court is whether the Georgia Insurance Code entitles the plaintiff to bring an action within three years after written proof of loss is required, notwithstanding a two-year provision in the insurance policy. Although the plaintiff relies on Code Ann. 56-3105 (7), this requirement of the Georgia Insurance Code applies solely to blanket accident and sickness insurance, but Code Ann. 56-3108, requiring certain claims provisions of group accident and insurance policies to be not less favorable than those in individual policies, has the effect of imposing the same three year requirement for group policies as set forth in Code Ann. 56-3004 (11). The Georgia Insurance Code became effective on January 1, 1961 (Code Ann. 56-115) and required compliance by persons acting as insurers in this State (Code Ann. 56-109), but it also allowed a minimum period of one year for the imposition of any requirement not existing under law in force immediately before the effective date. Code Ann. 56-110. As nothing appears in the petition to show that the group policy was issued subsequent to the effective date of the Georgia Insurance Code (in fact, the plaintiff concedes otherwise in his brief) and as the coverage became effective as to the plaintiff on October 1, 1961, within the grace period before the new requirements could become mandatory with respect to such a contract, the insured could rely on its right to enforce more restrictive limitations not contrary to laws previously in force.
Under these circumstances it is unnecessary to reach the issue of whether the three-year minimum limitation under the new law, if applied to an insurance contract already in force, would result in an unconstitutional application of a statute by impairing the obligation of a contract. See in this connection, however, Code 102-104; Cutts & Johnson v. Hardee, 38 Ga. 350, 366; George v. Gardner, 49 Ga. 441, 450; Dixie Constr. Co. v. Williams, 95 Ga. App. 767, 769 (98 SE2d 582); Terry v. Anderson, 95 U. S. 628 (24 LE 365); Smith & Marsh v. Northern Neck Mut. Fire Assn., 112 Va. 192 (70 SE 482).
As the petition affirmatively discloses that the action is barred by the provisions of the contract on which it is based, the trial judge properly sustained a general demurrer.
Judgment affirmed. Bell, P. J., and Pannell, J., concur.
Smith, Cohen, Ringel, Kohler, Martin & Lowe, Scott Charlton, for appellee.
Paul C. Myers, for appellant.
SUBMITTED APRIL 4, 1967 -- DECIDED MAY 16, 1967.
Friday May 22 19:43 EDT

This site exists because of donors like you.


Valid HTML 4.0!

Valid CSS!

Home - Tour - Disclaimer - Privacy - Contact Us
Copyright © 2000,2002,2004